Finally ready to start revising your dissertation into an academic book? Or, still working on your dissertation, but wondering what the book process ahead looks like? In this comprehensive guide, I answer all your questions about how to go from dissertation to book.
How should I start revising my dissertation into a book?
First, tackle your productivity habits.
Revising a dissertation into a book takes years, during which time you must sustain momentum and enthusiasm.
The best thing you can do to start has both nothing and everything to do with the book itself: laying the productivity foundation for a successful book.
What made the biggest difference for me was:
- starting an in-person writing group and long-distance writing partnership
- tracking my weekly and daily writing goals (or steal the done-for-you Google Forms system I developed!)
- using a container routine
- writing every day
- conducting a weekly writing review
Then, get a handle on your book as a book.
Start by working ON your book (instead of spinning your wheels working IN it).
Or, want my personal help getting a handle on your book’s main claim, structure, and how all the pieces fit together? We do just that in my dissertation-to-book boot camp.
Will publishers reject my book if my dissertation was published on ProQuest?
I, too, was extremely concerned about this issue. So, I embargoed my dissertation for the maximum amount of time my university allowed. But, it was available by the time my book came out.
However, the fact that my dissertation was on ProQuest was never something my publisher mentioned and was not an issue for my book at any point in the process.
What are the general steps to go from dissertation to book?
Assess Your Book as a Book
First, you should review your manuscript as the book it will become by working ON your book manuscript before working IN it. This involves making serious decisions about content, scope, and structure.
Revise Your Manuscript & Build Author Profile
While you are revising your manuscript thoroughly, you should also engage in activities that will establish you as an authority with the audiences you hope read your book. Attend and give solid papers at targeted conferences. Once you have done serious work ON your book, you can begin to establish connections with editors at conferences.
Prepare and Submit Proposals
After revising your manuscript thoroughly, you will be ready to prepare and submit proposals. (See my comprehensive post Academic Book Proposals: All Your Questions, Answered for more on this topic).
Manuscript Submission, Peer Reviews, Author Response & Contract
If a university press is interested in your book, they will request the full manuscript and send it to 2+ peer reviewers (usually in 1-2 rounds). If they are still interested, they will ask you to respond formally in writing, discussing how you will revise the manuscript. The editor will then present the whole package (proposal, manuscript, reviews, author response) to the editorial board. If successful, you will be issued a contract. Typically, this period lasts 3-6 months.
Final Manuscript Preparation & Delivery
Next, you will revise and submit the manuscript (and any permissions for copyrighted materials) to the press. (It might need to go back to peer review here, depending on the press and reviews).
Book Production & Publication
Once you submit the final manuscript, it will go into production. You might have to help the press identify cover images. You will receive and review proofs, respond to queries, and suggest changes. Once the manuscript is in its final form, you will have to complete the index (in a relatively short time) or hire someone to compile it. Generally, you will fill out author marketing forms at this point, before finally receiving your author copies in the mail.
Consensus among editors at top presses put the time between delivery of the final manuscript (not full, pre-peer reviewed manuscript!) and a book in hand at about 8-10 months (can range from 6-13 months).
For more details on how long each stage takes and how you can use your time and energy most efficiently in each, consult my comprehensive guide on the stages between dissertation and book.
How long will it take to go from dissertation to book?
The answer depends on many factors, only some of which you can control.
I can only speak concretely about how long my own dissertation to book journey took: 3 full academic years from dissertation to book in hand.
If a book is required for tenure, when should I submit proposals?
The answer depends on your institution, department, and academic press.
First, you need to clarify exactly what is required for tenure. A published book you can hold in your hand? A book “in press” (i.e. you have received proofs)? A book contract based on a proposal alone? A book contract for the whole manuscript?
These are all very different things.
Remember, too, that at most research-intensive institutions, your dossier will actually be submitted to external reviewers the summer after your 5th year (on a 6-year tenure clock). So, if you need a book out (in hand) by that point (end of year 5), then you probably need to submit proposals in year 3. Depending on press speed and whether your manuscript is accepted, however, even this might not be enough time.
Is it OK that my book’s structure is similar to my dissertation’s?
Most dissertation to book authors get overly hung up on the potential correspondence between dissertation and book.
When you revise your dissertation into a book, your structure needs to make sense for your book. Don’t keep a structure from dissertation to book just because it’s easy. On the other hand, don’t completely abandon your dissertation’s structure just to make your book look completely different.
My overarching structure did not change much between dissertation and book. However, that’s the structure that made the most sense for my argument.
How much new material do I need to add between dissertation and book?
As much as makes sense for your book project. Again, don’t just add material to make it different. Don’t keep it exactly the same to make it easy.
My book’s body was about 40% new material. I added one completely new chapter (chapter 5, my favorite), and chopped two others in half, replacing those pieces with completely new material. My introduction and conclusion were completely new.
What if my prose doesn’t change much from dissertation to book?
Again, this is not a problem per se. But most dissertations are written for a different purpose than a scholarly book. Consequently, they usually lack a clear “voice.” For more on the specific criteria that define dissertation and book style see Germano’s chapter 8.
How much material can (or should) I publish as articles before I publish my book?
This might surprise dissertation to book authors.
You should publish 1-2 key articles based on your manuscript in top journals read by your book’s audience before you submit your proposal.
Doing so actually helps you develop your “author platform.” In your book proposal, you will usually have to discuss your credentials (i.e. why are are you the one to write this book?). Having received a Ph.D. in the discipline, presented the material at top conferences, and published on the topics in top journals all testify to your reputation in the field(s).
That said, there is a limit to how much you can/should pre-publish. A good guideline is no more than 2 articles. For editors at top university presses, a good rule of thumb is 20-40%.
But, as Peter Momtchiloff (Oxford), underscores, it’s not just quantity, but relationship between the pre-published material and the book itself:
What really matters is that people who are acquainted with the author’s articles will feel that the book offers them significantly more than they can get from the articles (for these people are the primary readership for the book). So I think it’s generally important that the key ideas and arguments of the book should not be out there already. If we are going to talk quantitatively, I guess I would say this: if an author wanted to play safe, she might aim to ensure that no more than one-third of her manuscript was previously published. Having said that, some books are genuinely more than the sum of their parts.Peter Momtchiloff, OUP
Before submitting my proposal, I had published one article based on material in my book.
When should I approach presses about my book or submit proposals?
Every colleague I asked in my field said I should not prepare or submit my book proposal until my entire book manuscript was ready to go straight to peer reviewers.
I explain why I, too, recommend this approach in
- Academic Book Proposals: All Your Questions, Answered
- When Should You Submit your Academic Book Proposal?
- Should You Pitch your Academic Book to an Acquisitions Editor at a Conference? What to Consider.
How long will it take between when I submit proposals to when I receive the final book?
According to Lorri Hagman, executive editor at the University of Washington Press, you can expect this period to last two or more years at university presses. The review process can take “up to a year” and then the editing process “can easily take a year and a half.”
How long this phase takes depends on many factors, including whether your proposal and/or manuscript has to go through multiple rounds of peer review and how many sets of proofs your book goes through.
Have other dissertation to book questions not answered above? Or, want to share your own dissertation to book experience with me? Reach out by email! I’d love to hear from you!
Humanities First Book Author Inner Circle
Writing your first academic book in a humanities or qualitative social science discipline? Wondering how to manage such a large project? You don't have to struggle alone! Sign up, and I'll send you resources and advice to help you get a handle on your manuscript, find the best publisher, and develop productivity habits to get the book done.