• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Katelyn Knox

Helping Scholars Finish Strong First Books

  • Resources for…
    • Pre-Contract Dissertation-to-Book Authors
    • Pre-Contract Authors of non-Dissertation Books
    • Authors Working on their Book Proposal
    • Authors who already have a Book Contract
    • Authors Struggling to Prioritize the Book
    • All Blog Posts
  • Courses & Workshops
    • Write a Solid Book Title (Free!)
    • Workshopping Your First Book, Step by Step
    • Identify Your Book’s Audience and Find A Press
  • Ask Katelyn
  • First Book Workshop
Overcoming Academic Writer’s Block, Part 2: The Two Questions

Overcoming Academic Writer’s Block, Part 2: The Two Questions

last updated on September 26, 2017

Are you stuck with a stubborn academic conference paper, journal article, or book chapter? Are you experiencing academic writer’s block and are looking for unique solutions to help you get unstuck?


Today’s post draws together my earlier post on overcoming academic writer’s block by writing two sentences, and an incredibly useful exercise found in “Week 2” of Wendy Belcher’s superb book Writing Your Journal Article in Twelve Weeks

One most revolutionary ideas I took from Belcher’s workbook (which I can’t recommend highly enough for grad students and early career researchers) was her straightforward answer to what an article is. For Belcher, an article needs to be “organized around a single significant new idea that is demonstrably related to what has come before” (49). Simple yet elegant.

As Jensen illustrates in Write no Matter What, academic writers often subscribe to the “magnum opus myth”–the idea that publishable writing must revolutionize the field. This myth frightens many writers from making the incremental contributions that move their field forward. (Her other articles on academic writing myths [Google “Jensen writing myths”] are also well worth reading).

Despite what it sounds like, Belcher’s “single significant new idea” is not, in fact, the “magnum opus” approach. She identifies three ways journal articles can structure their “new idea”: 1) approach new evidence in an old way, 2) analyze old evidence in a new way; or 3) pair old approaches with old evidence in a new way.

Today we’re going to use this model in a way Belcher did not explicitly intend. We’re going to use models 1 (new evidence/old way) and 2 (old evidence in new way) to imagine what future scholars (including your future self) might do after having read your article or chapter.

In the previous activity, I talked about the “Two Sentence Method” for overcoming writer’s block. I asked you to complete the following two sentences:

After reading this article you will understand… So that you can…

Today you will make the “so you can” concrete. You will imagine how others might apply your methodology/argument (old way) to different texts (new evidence). You will also imagine how someone might approach those same texts/objects you analyze (old evidence) using a new lens or methodology (new way). Doing so should help you not only refine your own ideas, but also clarify how your article or chapter fits within scholarly terrain that will continue to evolve in the coming years.

Identifying what Scholars will DO with your work

Answer the following questions:

Question 1: Is my methodology portable?

Think about a scholar applying this model in a different field, and make a list of disciplines, texts, etc. in which you could reasonably see your methodology working. How might someone apply the model/methodology you develop in your publication to different (new) evidence?

Question 2: Can my work be complemented?

Think about what your approach must necessarily–and deliberately–leave out. How might someone approach the same evidence you do in your publication in a new way that complements yours? Note that answering this question gives you permission to deliberately and unapologetically keep your article’s focus narrow. You might even consider announcing those analyses that fall outside the scope of your article as a way to invite others to return to and engage your necessarily limited analyses.

Reflection

As always, doing the activity is only the first step. I strongly suggest you answer the following questions:

  • How can you use your answer to question 1 to foreground your methodology in a way that will be useful to other scholars ?
  • What did you learn about the general or particular applicability of your model/methodology in answering question 1? How will you use this knowledge to revise your publication?
  • I find answering question 2 liberating: it reminds us that we cannot do everything in the space of one article. What pieces of the current iteration of your project can be “let go” and revisited in a future project?
  • Finally, if this piece of writing is a journal article, reflect on whether you have selected the right venue for publication. If you discover your argument is more generalizable than you’d initially realized, consider targeting a publication with a broader scope. If its applicability appears narrower, consider targeting a more specialized journal. If you are still unsure about how to choose the right journal for the project, consult Wendy Belcher’s excellent advice on how to find a suitable journal for your article.

Have you tried the two questions? How did it work for you? I’d love to hear about it in the comments below or by email! Write on!

✕

Humanities First Book Author Inner Circle

Writing your first academic book in a humanities or qualitative social science discipline? Wondering how to manage such a large project? You don't have to struggle alone! Sign up, and I'll send you resources and advice to help you get a handle on your manuscript, find the best publisher, and develop productivity habits to get the book done.

Success! Now check your email and click on the button I sent you to confirm your address.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

I won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

Find this post Useful? Spread the word!

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Academic Writing, Productivity

Primary Sidebar

Get Real Book Publishing Answers



Katelyn Knox

Welcome! I’m Katelyn Knox, an Associate Professor of French. After my first book was published by a top UP in my field, I vowed to put together resources to help junior humanities scholars navigate book publishing more easily and with less stress. I now mentor junior humanities through boot camps, courses, and free resources.

Dissertation-to-Book Boot Camp

Stop feeling scattered, put together a solid outline and leave with a roadmap to finish the book in time.

 

Join the Inner Circle

Humanities First Book Author Inner Circle

Writing your first academic book in a humanities discipline? Wondering how to manage such a large project? You don't have to struggle alone! Sign up, and I'll send you resources and advice to help you get a handle on your manuscript, find the best publisher, and develop productivity habits to get the book done.

Success! Now check your email and click on the link I sent you to confirm your address.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

I won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

More Posts on

My Most Popular iPad Pro Posts

In-Depth Review of the iPad Pro for Professors and Academics

6 Essential Apps for Teaching with the iPad Pro

Which size iPad Pro is Best for Teaching (12.9 or 10.5)?

iPad Pro_ Hardware for the Classroom

What's the Difference between an iPad and an iPad Pro?

Affiliate Note

Note: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase using them, at no cost to you. I only recommend things that I truly believe will help you in the ways outlined below. For more details, see my full Disclosure Page.

Copyright © 2023 · Academy Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in